Ruth Prawer Jhabvala, Screenwriter, Dies at 85
Ruth Prawer Jhabvala, the German-born screenwriter and novelist who, as the writing member of the Merchant Ivory filmmaking team, won two Academy Awards for adaptations of genteel, class-conscious E. M. Forster novels, died on Wednesday at her home in Manhattan. She was 85.
James Ivory, the director with whom she collaborated, said the cause was complications of a pulmonary condition.
Mrs. Jhabvala (pronounced JOB-vahla) was already well established as an author when she began her screenwriting career with the producer Ismail Merchant and Mr. Ivory. Her 1975 novel, âHeat and Dust,â about an Englishwoman exploring a family scandal in India, received the Man Booker Prize, Britainâs highest literary honor. She wrote the screenplay for the Merchant Ivory version in 1983 as well.
Over four decades, beginning in 1963, Mrs. Jhabvala made 22 films with Mr. Merchant and Mr. Ivory, all examining culture in one way or another, often one that has vanished. Their first film to attract wide attention was âThe Europeansâ (1979), based on a Henry James novel set in mid-19th-century New England. Their successful âRoom With a Viewâ (1986), based on Forsterâs novel about a sheltered young Englishwoman who has a life-changing experience on holiday in Italy, brought Mrs. Jhabvala the Oscar for best adapted screenplay.
History repeated itself when she won the same award for Merchant Ivoryâs âHowards Endâ (1992), from a Forster book in which shifting Edwardian social classes cross paths with sometimes cruel results. The teamâs collaborations â" lush and literate, often adapted from classic novels â" became something of a brand. Visually, a Merchant Ivory film promised âperiod-perfect costumes and settingsâ (as The Los Angeles Times wrote); ârich production values and an exquisite attention to detailâ (The Minneapolis Star Tribune); or simply âtasteâ (The Chicago Tribune).
The casts were top-shelf and largely British, laden with stars like Maggie Smith, Anthony Hopkins, Emma Thompson, Daniel Day-Lewis, Helena Bonham Carter and Vanessa Redgrave. For âMr. & Mrs. Bridgeâ (1990), based on the Evan S. Connell novels, Paul Newman and Joanne Woodward, spouses in real life, were recruited for the title roles.
But Mrs. Jhabvalaâs writing was essential. She contributed sophisticated dialogue and a sharp eye for the nuances of class and ethnicity, Stephen Holden wrote in The New York Times. He also echoed a frequent complaint about Merchant Ivory productions, however, finding in them an âantique-shop sensibility and Anglo-European snob appeal.â
Mr. Merchant, who died in 2005, was Indian, and Mr. Ivory is American, but Mrs. Jhabvala brought a combination of cultural backgrounds to their film collaborations, which also included âThe Remains of the Dayâ (1993), based on Kazuo Ishiguroâs novel, and adaptations of two more Henry James novels, âThe Golden Bowlâ (2000) and âThe Bostoniansâ (1984).
Ruth Prawer was born on May 7, 1927, in Cologne, Germany, the daughter of Marcus Prawer, a Jewish lawyer who had immigrated there from Poland, and the former Eleanora Cohn. The family fled Hitler in 1939, when Ruth was 12. Unable to acquire visas for the United States, they settled in London instead. In 1948 Marcus Prawer committed suicide, having established that the entire family he had left behind in Poland had died in Nazi camps.
Ruth studied English literature at Queen Mary College, University of London, and received her degree in 1951. That year she married Cyrus Jhabvala, an Indian architect, and moved with him to Delhi, where she spent the next quarter-century as a privileged, somewhat reclusive housewife raising three daughters and writing novels about the new culture in which she found herself. Many readers assumed she was Indian.
After she wrote her first book, about a young Indian woman from a good family who falls in love with the wrong man, she sent the manuscript to her mother, who circulated it to British publishers. It was published there in 1955 as âTo Whom She Willâ and in the United States the next year as âAmrita.â It was followed by âThe Nature of Passionâ (1956) and âEsmond in Indiaâ (1957).
Once Mrs. Jhabvala had an American agent, her short stories began appearing in The New Yorker. Critics praised her satiric voice and compared her to Jane Austen, among others.
She continued to write fiction long after her film career had made her famous, shifting her focus gradually to the immigrant experience and European exiles in America. Her 12th and most recent novel, âMy Nine Livesâ (2004), posited several alternative paths her life might have taken, in New York, London, Delhi and elsewhere.
Her last short-story collection, âA Lovesong for India,â was published in 2012, and her last story for The New Yorker appeared in its March 25 issue. The story, âThe Judgeâs Will,â tells of a long-married woman in Delhi dealing with the news, and presence, of her husbandâs longtime mistress.
It was her fiction that had brought Mr. Merchant and Mr. Ivory to her door. In the early 1960s, when the two men had made only a handful of films together, they approached Mrs. Jhabvala to write a screenplay based on her novel âThe Householder,â about the trials of a young Indian husband. The film, made in India in black and white, was released in the United States in 1963. She shared writing credit with Mr. Ivory for a few of the teamâs early films, including âShakespeare Wallahâ (1965), âThe Guruâ (1969) and âBombay Talkieâ (1970).
In the 1970s Mrs. Jhabvala moved to New York, where, as she wrote in her 1979 essay âDisinheritance,â she felt a connection to her early years.
âI met the people I went to school with in Cologne, with exactly the same background as my own, same heritage, same parentage,â she wrote. âNow here they were living in New York, as Americans, in old West Side apartments.â
Her marriage endured, with Mrs. Jhabvala spending several months a year in India and her husband paying her long visits in New York until he retired and they were able to reunite full time.
The last film the three Merchant Ivory principals made together was âLe Divorceâ (2003), a contemporary story about Americans in Paris based on Diane Johnsonâs novel. After Mr. Merchantâs death, Mrs. Jhabvala and Mr. Ivory worked together on âThe City of Your Final Destinationâ (2009), another literary adaptation, of the Peter Cameron novel, set on an estate in Uruguay inhabited by Europeans, played by Laura Linney and Mr. Hopkins.
Holding dual British and American citizenship, she was made a Commander of the Order of the British Empire, for her service to literature, in 1998.
In addition to her husband, she is survived by her daughters, Renana Jhabvala, Firoza Jhabvala and Ava Jhabvala Wood; and six grandchildren.
In the end, Mrs. Jhabvala lived in New York longer than in any other place, but that didnât mean she saw the city as home.
âOnce a refugee, always a refugee,â she told The Guardian in 2005. âI canât ever remember not being all right wherever I was, but you donât give your whole allegiance to a place or want to be entirely identified with the society youâre living in.â
Daniel E. Slotnik contributed reporting.
This article has been revised to reflect the following correction:
Correction: April 3, 2013
An earlier version of this article incorrectly credited Ruth Prawer Jhabvala as a screenwriter on âMauriceâ; Kit Heskit-Harvey collaborated with the director James Ivory as screenwriters for that 1987 film, which was adapted from the E. M. Forster novel. It also referred incorrectly to school where she studied English literature. It is Queen Mary College, University of London, not St. Mary College.
No comments:
Post a Comment