Total Pageviews

Friday, November 30, 2012

Iranian Channel Reports Bomb Outside Its Office in Damascus

Iran's state-owned satellite channel Press TV reports that a bomb destroyed six vehicles, including a satellite news truck near the broadcaster's office in Damascus early on Friday.

Video posted on a YouTube account associated with Hussein Mortada, a Lebanese supporter of the Syrian government who directs coverage of Syria for Press TV and the Iranian government's Arabic-language satellite channel, Al Alam, was said to capture the blast. The surveillance-camera video is quite dark but, according to Press TV, the bombing took place just “after a man was caught on camera sticking something to a car.”

Video said to show an explosion in Damascus early on Friday outside the office of an Iranian satellite channel.

A second video clip posted on the same YouTube account on Friday, despite reports that the Internet remains down in Syria, appeared to offer a glimpse of a road near the airport in Damascus, and a government checkpoint, with the sounds of fighting in the distance. Fighting was reported near the airport on Thursday.

Video said to show a road near the airport in Damascus, the Syrian capital, on Friday.



Should Health Care for the Very Poor Be a Fast-Growth Business?

Shushila Varmar lies with her newborn in a Primary Health Center, a rural clinic catering for basic needs, in Kurebhar, Uttar Pradesh. The growing Daniel Etter for The New York TimesShushila Varmar lies with her newborn in a Primary Health Center, a rural clinic catering for basic needs, in Kurebhar, Uttar Pradesh. The growing affordable health care industry hopes to provide more services for India's rural population which does not have access to state clinics like this one.

NEW DELHI - Health care experts, investors and government officials gathered at New Delhi's Habitat Cen ter on Friday to discuss one of the most promising new investment areas in India: affordable health care.

You'd be forgiven for finding the name a bit confusing - after all, who wants health care that isn't affordable, no matter how much money you have? The term here refers to health care for those at the “bottom of the pyramid” - in other words, poor people.

India is viewed as one of this new industry's most exciting markets, as Jyoti Pande Lavakare wrote on India Ink this week, in part because there are so many people here who are not receiving adequate health care: the industry aims at the 835 million people in India earning less than 250 rupees, or $4.50, per day.

“We can't think of a more important sector with greater social impact than affordable health care in India,” Jasjit Mangat, director of investment at the Omidyar Network, told Ms. Pande Lavakare. Private-sector annual revenues, he estimates, could be up to $20 billion in India alone.

But behind the excitement about the promised growth of the industry lies a fundamental question that needs to be addressed: Should providing health care to very poor people be a business at all?

The venture capital community's move into the affordable health care business is just the latest example of the “doing well by doing good” phenomenon. Some companies and investment funds have embraced the notion in recent years that being socially responsible and caring for employees also helps boost profits. The idea has been touted by Harvard Business School professors and  debated by the likes of Bill Gates and Larry Summers.

Entrepreneurs and venture capitalists, under the umbrella of “doing well by doing good,” have particularly seized on the idea of “impact investing,” or applying a businesslike approach to what may once have been a charitable enterprise. Expecting a definite return, whether it's profit or tangible resu lts, helps ensure that funds and services get more efficiently to those who need them and ensures that they keep coming, they say.

Enthusiasm for this approach, and a significant amount of money along with it, reached a peak recently in India with the for-profit microfinance industry. The end result, though, was disaster: dozens of women committed suicide after being pushed into loans they could not repay.

For-profit groups' jump into the industry led to its collapse in India, Lydia Polgreen and Vikas Bajaj wrote in November of 2010:

Vijay Mahajan, the chairman of Basix, an organization that provides loans and other services to the poor, acknowledged that many lenders grew too fast and lent too aggressively. Investments by private equity firms and the prospect of a stock market listing drove firms to increase lending as fast as they could, he said.

“In their quest to grow,” he said, “they kept piling on more loans in the same geograp hies.” He added, “That led to more indebtedness, and in some cases it led to suicides.”

The biggest proponent of for-profit microfinance in India, Vikram Akula, founder of S.K.S. Microsystems, subsequently admitted that his approach was a mistake.

“Bringing private capital into social enterprise was much harder than I anticipated,” he said at a Harvard University conference. Mr. Akula blamed his own “focus on scaling S.K.S.'s model” without anticipating the “potential downside” - in other words, trying to grow the business without looking at the harmful consequences of pushing for growth.

At Friday's conference on affordable health care in Delhi, there are sessions titled “From Product to Market” and “Rethink Access,” but nothing on what a reasonable rate of growth is to keep the industry ethical, or how investors plan to ensure that poor people will not be pressured into spending money on health care they don't need.< /p>

For the affordable health care industry to truly become one, these are issues that need to be thoroughly addressed, experts say.

“It is all very well for companies to come in to invest in any social sector, so long as they are willing to temper their expectations and earn a reasonable return,” said Sanjay Sinha, the managing director of M-CRIL, a microcredit rating agency based in Gurgaon, India.

But affordable health care enthusiasts, like any social investors, should learn from the microfinance industry's troubles, he said. “Usually these companies get so excited about the growth opportunities that they think growth can go on forever,” he said, “and that's where problems arise.”



Reading Egypt\'s Draft Constitution

As my colleagues Kareem Fahim and David Kirkpatrick report from Cairo, Tahrir Square was filled with protesters again on Friday as opponents of President Mohamed Morsi, “galvanized and angered by his unexpected and hurried effort to pass Egypt's new constitution,” returned to the streets.

The Cairene blogger who writes as The Big Pharaoh observed that the square was full, if not as jammed as it had been three days ago, when Egyptians rallied in numbers that recalled the 18 days of protest that toppled Hosni Mubarak.

Video of Tuesday's rally, posted on YouTube by activists from the Mosireen collective, testified to the size and passion of the new protest movement against the Islamist president and the draft constitution app roved by his allies in a constituent assembly packed with his supporters.

Video of Tuesday's protests in Cairo, from the activist film collective Mosireen.

Since the new constitution has to be approved in a referendum, that document is now the focus of intense scrutiny. Hours after it was approved, The Egypt Independent published an English translation of the Arabic text prepared by Nariman Youssef. Ms. Youssef, who describes herself as “a literary translator, wannabe cultural historian and sometimes poet” on her blog, Multivalence, voiced some criticism of the text as she worked.

The BBC produced a very useful side-by-side comparison of important parts of the new document to those in Egypt's previous constitution. Issandr El Amrani, the Cairo-based journalist who blogs as The Arabist, suggested that the comparison was not flattering to the new text.

As the constituent assembly raced to pass the document on Thursday and Friday, in the absence of non-Islamist members who boycotted the proceedings, Heba Morayef, the Human Rights Watch Egypt director, provided a running and quite frequently lacerating commentary on Twitter.

Several of Ms. Morayef's objections were incorporated into an analysis of the draft constitution published by Human Rights Watch on Friday.

The rights group welcomed some parts of the text, but expressed concern about seve ral others.

Human Rights Watch has reviewed Chapter II of the final draft, entitled Rights and Freedoms, and followed the televised session in which the constituent assembly voted on each of these provisions. The rights chapter provides for strong protection against arbitrary detention in article 35 and torture and inhumane treatment in article 36, and for freedom of movement in article 42, privacy of communication in article 38, freedom of assembly in article 50, and of association in article 51. But the latest draft, unlike the earlier version, defers to objections from the country's military leadership and has removed the clear prohibition of trials of civilians before military courts.

Human Rights Watch also identified and explained in detail its concerns over limited guarantees of freedom of expression, freedom of religion and women's rights in the new framework for Egyptian law.

Gehad El-Haddad, a senior adviser to the Muslim Brotherhood and the group's political party, which nominated Mr. Morsi for the presidency earlier this year, sparred with critics, including Ms. Morayef on Twitter.

The author Rawah Badrawi, who lives outside Cairo, observed that the referendum campaign was already underway, at least for Mr. Morsi's allies in the Muslim Brotherhood, and the opposition might need to develop a “ground game” to defeat the draft constitution rather than just focus on street demonstrations.

Evidence that the campaign in favor of the draft constitution has begun was posted online by Egyptian blogger - a photograph of a Muslim Brotherhood flyer, reportedly being passed out in Alexandria, Egypt's second-largest city.

The flyer seeks to undermine a series of objections to the draft constitution, with the help of clip art and answers to what are presented as common misconceptions.

The first panel of the flyer is a response to a voter who says, “I heard that non-Muslims won't be able to take their rights in this country!” The response reads:

What did I hear? Instead of listening to other people, see for yourself. You haven't got the draft - so come here. What is it you are saying? This constitution gave everyone rights that were not there before. Like Article 3, which says that non-Muslims - Christians and Jews - have the right to be governed by their own laws in regards to personal status. And article 27 says that freedom of thought is protected and that the state ensures freedom to establish houses of worship within the confines of the law.

But, as Human Rights Watch notes, “Article 43 on freedom of religion limits the right to practice religion and to establish places of worship to Muslims, Christians, and Jews. Previous drafts had provided for a general right to practice religion but limited the establishment of places of worship to adherents of these three Abrahamic religions. Article 43 discriminates against and excludes followers of other religions, including Egyptian Bahais.”



Five Ways Indian Internet Users Are Fighting for Free Speech

People work on computers at an office in Bangalore, Karnataka, in this Feb. 29, 2012 file photo.Vivek Prakash/ReutersPeople work on computers at an office in Bangalore, Karnataka, in this Feb. 29, 2012 file photo.

The two young women who were arrested for their Facebook activity last week have found an unlikely champion for their cause: another young woman, Shreya Singhal, who filed public interest litigation with the Supreme Court to challenge one of the controversial laws used to justify the arrests.

That litigation was heard by the Supreme Court on Friday, which then ordered the central and some state governments to respond within six weeks. Ms. Singhal, who is a recent astrophysics graduate and plans to apply to law school, questioned the constitutionality of Section 66A. The dreary sounding, but much-talked about law criminalizes information sent online that can be considered “offensive.”

Although not many have petitioned the Supreme Court like the 21-year-old Ms. Singhal, thousands of social media users, civil society groups, lawyers and activists have protested Section 66A and the Internet laws in recent weeks. If readers believe the laws are muzzling online free speech, here are some ways experts offer to keep up the pressure to scrap the law:

  1. ONLINE PETITIONS:

Change.org, which Nicholas D. Kristof of The New York Times describes as “the go-to site for Web uprisings,” has a petition that requests the minister for information and communication technology to amend Section 66A and relook at the Internet laws. Gautam John, a trained lawyer who now strategizes for nonprofits, started the petition on Tuesday to offer citizens a space to register their protest.

Although Mr. John acknowledged that the petition is unlikely to change the law, he still believes it's an important resource to document people's protest.

“One of the reasons why I support this petition in particular is because it offers very concrete suggestions, rather than just slamming the government,” Nilanjana Roy, a literary critic, journalist and author, said via email. “It points out a major area of concern: the government has a history of passing laws about the Internet in particular without involving stakeholders, or paying attention to the opinions and experiences of those who understand social media networks and online behavior patterns. Given the speed at which the Internet evolves and changes, this is a huge problem,” she said.

And maybe online petitions do work.

Another campaign on Change.org demanded that the charges against the women booked for their Facebook activity be dropped.

“This move by the police is a gross clamp down on an individual's freedom of speech and expression,” said Mukut Ray, 28, an activist from Kolkata who started the online petition, according to a statement. More than 21,000 supporters signed it.

Although it's difficult to gauge the role the petition had to play, charges against the women have reportedly been dropped.

2. LOBBYING LEADERS:

Citizens can lobby their political leaders to take actions on issues they care about, analysts say.

“We don't contact our elected representatives enough,” said Mr. John, who recommends interested people to go to the Web sites of Parliament's upper house, known as the Rajya Sabha, or the lower house, Lok Sabha, to find contact details for their representatives.

“Politicians should know it's not just a small bunch of people who are concerned,” argued Mr. John. “There are a large number and they have an opinion, too.”

One lawyer who's famil iar with the Internet laws controversy, said Kapil Sabil, the minister for communications and information technology, is the right man to lobby. This is the contact page for his ministry.

3. GO TO COURT

People can file public interest litigation like Ms. Singhal did at the Supreme Court. Legal experts say that any citizen can write a letter to the High Court in their state or to the Supreme Court, which can then decide to file public interest litigation on behalf of the citizen.

This retired physics professor had also filed litigation with the Madras High Court earlier this month asking the government to repeal section 66A, which he called “arbitrary and unconstitutional.” The court responded to his request last week, serving notice to state officials, as well as the secretaries of India's home, law and information and broadcasting ministries, asking them to respond to the lawsuit in four weeks.

“I think at this point groups with expertise on th e issue should file petitions in the Supreme Court, to be heard with the law student's petition,” said Karuna Nundy, a lawyer and civil liberties expert, who filed a more comprehensive petition along with Ms. Singhal's on behalf of the People's Union for Civil Liberties, a prolific human rights group.

4. SOCIAL MEDIA ENGAGEMENT

Citizens can continue to engage on Facebook and Twitter about the controversial laws.

Pranesh Prakash, policy director of the Centre for Internet and Society, notes that many traditional journalists are on social media sites and are bound to notice if users are protesting there.

Indeed. Many media outlets drew attention to the outcry on Facebook and Twitter that followed the arrest of the women for their Facebook activity.

5. GO OFFLINE

Offline protests are scheduled by Free Software Movement of India, a coalition of groups that lobby for free software, free knowledge, and a free society. The coalition demands tha t the central government review the Information Technology Act.

“Free Software Movement of India condemns the misuse of 66A and calls for protests across the country from 1st December 2012 to 7th December 2012,” the organization said on its Web site. “As a minimum it should come out with clear rules under the Act clearly limiting the scope of Section 66A and others to be in conformity with the freedom of expression guaranteed under the Article 19 of the Indian Constitution.”

Go to their Web site for a look at what's happening in your city.

If users can think of other ways to make a difference, feel free to note them in the comments section below.



Image of the Day: Nov. 30

An AIDS awareness rally in Kolkata, West Bengal, on the eve of World AIDS Day.Piyal Adhikary/European Pressphoto AgencyAn AIDS awareness rally in Kolkata, West Bengal, on the eve of World AIDS Day.

Should Health Care for the Very Poor Be a Fast-Growth, For-Profit Business?

Shushila Varmar lies with her newborn in a Primary Health Center, a rural clinic catering for basic needs, in Kurebhar, Uttar Pradesh. The growing Daniel Etter for The New York TimesShushila Varmar lies with her newborn in a Primary Health Center, a rural clinic catering for basic needs, in Kurebhar, Uttar Pradesh. The growing “affordable health care” industry hopes to provide more services for India's rural population which does not have access to state clinics like this one.

NEW DELHI- Health care experts, investors and government officials are gathered at New Delhi's Ha bitat Center today to discuss one of the most promising new investment areas in India: affordable health care.

You'd be forgiven for finding the name a bit confusing â€" after all, who wants health care that isn't affordable, no matter how much money you have? The term here refers to health care for those at the “bottom of the pyramid,” or in other words, poor people.

India is viewed as one of this new industry's most exciting markets, as Jyoti Pande Lavakare wrote on India Ink this week, in part because there are so many people here who are not receiving adequate health care: the industry aims at the 835 million people in India earning less than 250 rupees, or $4.50, per day.

“We can't think of a more important sector with greater social impact than affordable health care in India,” Jasjit Mangat, director of investment at the Omidyar Network, told Ms. Pande Lavakare. Private sector annual revenues, he estimates, could be up to $20 billion in India alone.

But behind the excitement about the promised growth of the industry lies a fundamental question that needs to be addressed: Should providing health care to very poor people be a for-profit business at all?

The venture capital community's move into the “affordable health care” business is just the latest example of the “doing well by doing good” phenomenon. Some companies and investment funds have embraced the notion in recent years that being socially responsible and caring for employees also helps boost profits. The idea has been touted by Harvard Business School professors and  debated by the likes of Bill Gates and Larry Summers.

Entrepreneurs and venture capitalists, under the umbrella of “doing well by doing good,” have particularly seized on the idea of “impact investing,” or applying a businesslike approach to what may once have been a charitable enterprise. Expecting a definite return, whether it 's profit or tangible results, helps ensure that funds and services get more efficiently to those who need them and ensures that they keep coming, they say.

Enthusiasm for this approach, and a significant amount of money along with it, reached a peak recently in India with the for-profit microfinance industry. The end result, though, was tragedy: dozens of women committed suicide after being pushed into loans they could not repay.

For-profit groups' jump into the industry led to its collapse in India, Lydia Polgreen and Vikas Bajaj wrote in November of 2010:

Vijay Mahajan, the chairman of Basix, an organization that provides loans and other services to the poor, acknowledged that many lenders grew too fast and lent too aggressively. Investments by private equity firms and the prospect of a stock market listing drove firms to increase lending as fast as they could, he said.

“In their quest to grow,” he said, “they kept piling on more loans in the same geographies.” He added, “That led to more indebtedness, and in some cases it led to suicides.”

The biggest proponent of for-profit microfinance in India, Vikram Akula, founder of S.K.S. Microsystems, subsequently admitted that his approach was a mistake.

“Bringing private capital into social enterprise was much harder than I anticipated,” he said at a Harvard University conference. Mr. Akula blamed his own “focus on scaling S.K.S.'s model” without anticipating the “potential downside” â€" in other words, trying to grow the business without looking at the harmful consequences of pushing for growth.

At Friday's conference on “affordable health care” in Delhi, there are sessions like “From Product to Market” and “Rethink Access,” but nothing on what a reasonable rate of growth is to keep the industry ethical, or how investors plan to ensure that poor people will not be pressured into spending money o n health care they don't need.

For the “affordable health care industry” to truly become one, these are issues that need to be thoroughly addressed, experts say.

“It is all very well for companies to come in to invest in any social sector, so long as they are willing to temper their expectations and earn a reasonable return,” said Sanjay Sinha, the managing director of M-CRIL, a microcredit rating agency based in Gurgaon, India.

But affordable health care enthusiasts, like any social investors, should learn from the microfinance industry's troubles, he said. “Usually these companies get so excited about the growth opportunities that they think growth can go on forever,” he said, “and that's where problems arise.”



At the Doha Summit, India Pushes Developed Nations to Cut Emissions

Senior negotiator Meera Mehrishi addressing a press conference at the United Nations climate change conference in Doha, Qatar, on Thursday.Courtesy of Betwa SharmaSenior negotiator Meera Mehrishi addressing a press conference at the United Nations climate change conference in Doha, Qatar, on Thursday.

DOHA, Qatar - At the United Nations climate change talks in Doha, India is taking an active role in asking developed nations to commit to ambitious carbon dioxide emission cuts and pledge money to combat the global challenge.

Delegates from 194 countries are attending a two-week-long annual conference on climate change here, which concludes on Dec. 7.

So far, developed nations have been mostly unresponsive to India's push. The European Union has agreed to 20 percent carbon emission cuts from 1990 levels for the period of 2013 to 2020, a level that advocates for cuts say had already been pledged earlier. This time frame is known as the “second commitment period” of the Kyoto Protocol, which is the only legally binding treaty on climate change. Four developed countries â€" Japan, New Zealand, Canada and Russia â€" have already backed out of the 1997 Kyoto Protocol.

“We are disappointed, however, that the developed countries are in the process of locking in low ambitions under this second commitment period,” Meera Mehrishi, India's chief negotiator, said Thursday. “We call on them to raise their level of ambition consistent with what is required by science.”

The United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change estimated in a 2007 report that a 25 to 40 percent reduction of greenhouse gases from 1990 level s is needed to limit the earth's temperature rise to two degrees Celsius.

The United States, which is not a party to the Kyoto Protocol, remains firm on a position far from the goals the panel set: reducing carbon emissions by 17 percent from 2005 levels, an estimated 4 percent from 1990 levels.

Developing countries, meanwhile, are pushing developed countries, in and out of the treaty, to take emission cuts of 30 to 40 percent compared to 1990 levels. Developed nations should shoulder the burden of climate change, developing nations believe, because of their share of historical carbon emissions as well as poorer nations' need to develop now.

Developing countries are of the view that climate change negotiations must be based on the principles of “equity” and “common but differentiated responsibility” in the U.N. Framework Convention on Climate Change, adopted in 1992, from which these negotiations emerged.

Still, the rapid growth of developing nations like China, India, Brazil and South Africa over the last decade has led the developed countries to distance themselves from these principles. China, for instance, is now the world's largest emitter of carbon dioxide, followed by the United States.

So far, large developing countries have only agreed to voluntary reductions in their carbon intensity, that is, the amount of carbon dioxide emitted per dollar generated by the country. India, for instance, has set a target of reducing emission intensity by 20 to 25 percent from 2005 levels by 2020.

Ms. Mehrishi noted that India's economic slowdown during the past year, from growth of almost 9 percent to just 5.5 percent, had resulted in a reduction of its emission intensity as well.

“It's just that the overall economic scenario in the world has also now impacted our country,” she said. “Earlier, we were quite comfortable, we do have a problem now.”

Meena Raman from the Third World Network, a n international climate advocacy organization, said that since European Union countries had already committed to 20 percent emission cuts so there have been no improvements during the Doha talks.

“What the E.U. is coming to Doha with is essentially to do nothing for the next eight years, and the United States refuses to even talk about reviewing its pledge and raising its ambitions,” she said.  “Developing countries across the board are very upset at the low level of ambition.”

Developing countries also see little progress on the goal of mobilizing $100 billion by 2020 for the issue.  The so-called Green Climate Fund, set up after the 2010 talks in Cancun, Mexico, has been referred to as an “empty shell” by some negotiators.

“We do not have any kind of really meaningful initial capitalization of the Green Climate Fund,” Bernarditas Muller, a negotiator from the Philippines, told delegates here. “Not a single cent that we could use in ord er to give to fulfill its functions of financing the needs of developing countries.”

At Doha, the United States is pushing the international community to focus on a post-2020 regime, agreed to at the 2011 climate talks at Durban, South Africa, which will legally bind both developed and developing nations to reduce their carbon emissions.

The European Union, meanwhile, agreed to extend the Kyoto Protocol, which would have ended this year, only after developing countries agreed to the post-2020 agreement called the Durban Platform.

While the Durban Platform opens up a new front for negotiations, developing countries want previous commitments under discussion since the 2007 climate talks in Bali, Indonesia, to be brought to a logical end.

Ms. Mehrishi stressed that India's agreement to the Durban Platform was based on reassurances that outstanding issues of mitigation, adaptation and technology under the Bali Action Plan would be addressed.  “We are therefore here in Doha to ensure that both of these are done satisfactorily,” she said.

China echoed India's sentiments.

“We need to make the necessary arrangements for the implementation of all the actions we had agreed to undertake,” Su Wei, China's chief negotiator, said this week.

The United States, however, is calling for a fresh start saying previous commitments only represented a bit more than 15 percent of global emissions.

“The task here at Doha is to close out the negotiations under the Bali round and to move on,” Jonathan Pershing, a senior negotiator from the United States, told the media this week.  “The new agreement must be built not for the world of 2007, when we adopted Bali, nor for 1997 or 1992, when we adopted the Kyoto Protocol and the convention respectively, but for the world of 2020 and beyond.”



Thursday, November 29, 2012

New York Dals

New York Dals

Sam Kaplan for The New York Times. Food stylist: Brett Kurzweil. Prop stylist: Randi Brookman Harris.

It is not that I've never cooked dal, the family of Indian legume dishes that is a staple for the hundreds of millions of vegetarians of India, as well as who knows how many millions of omnivores; it's just that I've never cooked it especially well. I realized this when I first visited northern India about 10 years ago and - even in a Sikh langar, a canteen where food is free for all - ate dal that was infinitely tastier than my own.

Cooking Dal Tarka Close Video See More Videos '

Part of that, probably, was the thrill of eating food where it belongs, and part of it was that many dals contain unconscionable amounts of ghee, a form of clarified butter. (Western Europe is not the only part of the world where cooks have recognized that butter makes many things taste much better.)

But part of it was some lack of feel for making dal, a kind of ignorance that I couldn't overcome simply by experimenting or following cookbooks. As legumes have become a more important part of my cooking, I decided that my dal problem needed to be remedied. I turned to Julie Sahni.

Sahni is an architect by training, but while teaching Indian cooking on the side, she was “discovered” in 1974 and written about in The Times by Florence Fabricant. Her first two books, published over the next decade - “Classic Indian Cooking” and “Classic Indian Vegetarian and Grain Cooking” - were instrumental in helping me gain a foothold in that cuisine, and I was thrilled to meet her in 1988 when she wrote an article for Cook's magazine while I was editor there. We've been friends since, and according to her, I've been threatening to make her teach me how to cook dal for most of that time.

We finally got together this fall, first on neutral ground at a cooking school and shop called Haven's Kitchen in Manhattan, where we taped a video, and later at her Brooklyn apartment. For me, these were - on an obviously small scale - life-changing events.

I learned that there are three or four things to know in cooking dal. One is that although you can cook any beans using these techniques and spices, you're not likely to get the ideal consistency unless you shop for Indian legumes. (Sahni recommends that New Yorkers shop at Foods of India in Manhattan or Patel Brothers in Queens, but almost any Indian food market sells legumes.)

Dal is sometimes made with whole beans (or lentils, or dried peas, but I'll use the word “legumes” to include all of these), but they tend to be smaller than their North American relatives. They are also often peeled and split. This means they cook faster - half an hour is generally long enough to make many dals - and break down quickly.

That texture is enhanced by a mathani, a kind of wooden beater or churner reminiscent of the molinillo used to froth Mexican hot chocolate. A mathani is fun to use - you rub the dowel end between your palms to twirl the action end in the dal, semi-puréeing it - but a whisk works pretty well, too, as might a molinillo, for that matter.

The texture can be adjusted to your preference, and made quite thin and soupy or very thick, but it's almost always semi-puréed with the mathani and therefore a bit creamy. You're not going to get authentic dal texture by simply cooking a pot of ordinary chickpeas with Indian spices.

But flavor is no less important: each of the recipes here is seasoned differently from the start, and if you want to be traditional, you will follow them to the letter. This isn't a problem with a decently stocked spice cabinet. (You can get all the spices you need at the markets mentioned above or at sites like penzeys.com.)

You should also carefully follow instructions for the tadka - heated ghee or oil and spices. The tadka is the finishing touch, unparalleled in its brilliance and simplicity, and pairing the correct tadka with its designated dal is if not critical then at least desirable. To make it, you take ghee or what's now called “vegetable ghee” (you can call this “oil,” because that's what it is) and heat it with seeds, spices and, usually, some kind of onions, often to a degree that other cuisines might consider “overcooked.” The tadka is poured into the dal just before serving, and the whole thing explodes with fragrance and flavor.

I cooked these four recipes with Sahni, and then I went shopping and went home and cooked them again. The results were consistent: most of the dals cooked quickly and reliably, and I used my mathanito make them creamy. The called-for spicing was accurate (and delicious), and the tadkas put them over the top. I even started carrying little bags of legumes and spices with me, began cooking them in friends' kitchens and - as is typical for me - began to ignore the recipes.

Yesterday - not at home, so I was at a disadvantage, pantrywise - I cooked chana dal (a small, peeled split chickpea) with an onion, a cinnamon stick, a small piece of nutmeg and some coriander seeds; I used a whisk because I'd left my trusty mathani at home. For the tadka, I heated safflower oil with mustard seeds and a few cloves; when the seeds popped, I cooked slivered garlic in there until it was quite brown and poured the whole thing on top. I served this to a small crowd of six, over brown rice and garnished with cilantro. Everyone was happy.

In a way, what I did was traditional: I used the right dal; I paid attention to texture; I made a tadka. I suppose a staunch traditionalist might say it was an abomination: my spicing was all over the place and possibly all wrong. (I did not consult Sahni before cooking and take full responsibility for my heretical actions.) Nevertheless, the results were pleasing to everyone, and it seemed like “real” dal to all of us. I'm pleased to report that I think I'm making real progress.

A version of this article appeared in print on December 2, 2012, on page MM52 of the Sunday Magazine with the headline: New York Dals.

The Tibetan Cause Is Not Hopeless, Leader Says

Lobsang Sangay, leader of the Tibetan government-in-exile, in Dharamsala, Himachal Pradesh, on March 29, 2012.Kuni Takahashi for The New York TimesLobsang Sangay, leader of the Tibetan government-in-exile, in Dharamsala, Himachal Pradesh, on March 29, 2012.

The cause of Tibetan independence is not hopeless, Lobsang Sangay, leader of the Tibetan government-in-exile, said in an interview Thursday.

“There is hope, primarily because of the Tibetan spirit and their continuing assertion of identity, and the sense of unity and solidarity inside and outside of Tibet has never been stronger,” Mr. Sangay said.

Mr. Sangay likened the Tibetan struggle to those of the Baltic republics of Estonia, Latvia a nd Lithuania during the Cold War. Soviet occupation of those countries seemed irreversible in the 1970s, he said, but the convulsive changes that followed the fall of the Berlin Wall eventually led to their independence.

“I remember talking to people from the Baltic States, and I asked them, ‘Did you really believe in the 1980s that you would get back your homeland?'” Mr. Sangay said. “And they said, ‘In our heads, no. In our hearts, yes.'”

Mr. Sangay was elected last year to be the Tibetan prime minister, or Sikyong, making him the leader of the Tibetan government-in-exile following the Dalai Lama's decision to surrender his governmental responsibilities to focus solely on his religious duties.

The government has about 1,000 employees and $22 million in annual revenues, which result from a voluntary tax on Tibetans as well as grants from governments and nongovernmental organizations. His government oversees 32 refugee schools located mostly in India and has recently launched a private health insurance scheme to protect Tibetan refugees from financial catastrophe following a family illness.

Mr. Sangay spoke while seated in a modest office building in New Delhi that serves as his government's embassy to the Indian government, its most important patron. Some 90,000 Tibetan exiles live in India, the most in the world.

He has proposed to the Chinese government what he said was a modest plan that would make Tibet an autonomous region within China. The Chinese have rejected the plan outright, he said.

He said that China's increasing economic and political might would help the Tibetan cause.

“Yes, China is gaining influence, but are they gaining respect?” he asked. “You gain respect by respecting your people first.”

He noted that most Tibetans who are protesting Chinese rule were born long after Tibet was annexed by China.

“So even after 60 y ears, the Chinese government has yet to convince the Tibetan people that they should be under them,” Mr. Sangay said.

Mr. Sangay lives in Dharamsala, with the rest of the Tibetan government-in-exile. He left his job as a senior fellow at Harvard to take up the post of prime minister, for which he is paid about $360 a month. His wife and 6-year-old daughter remain in Massachusetts.



Cultivating Vultures to Restore a Mumbai Ritual

Giving New Life to Vultures to Restore a Human Ritual of Death

Kuni Takahashi for The New York Times

A model of one of the Towers of Silence, top, where in Parsi tradition, dead bodies are placed for disposal by vultures.

MUMBAI, India - Fifteen years after vultures disappeared from Mumbai's skies, the Parsi community here intends to build two aviaries at one of its most sacred sites so that the giant scavengers can once again devour human corpses.

A funeral hall floor marks a place for a body.

Construction is scheduled to begin as soon as April, said Dinshaw Rus Mehta, chairman of the Bombay Parsi Punchayet. If all goes as planned, he said, vultures may again consume the Parsi dead by January 2014.

“Without the vultures, more and more Parsis are choosing to be cremated,” Mr. Mehta said. “I have to bring back the vultures so the system is working again, especially during the monsoon.”

The plan is the result of six years of negotiations between Parsi leaders and the Indian government to revive a centuries-old practice that seeks to protect the ancient elements - air, earth, fire and water - from being polluted by either burial or cremation. And along the way, both sides hope the effort will contribute to the revival of two species of vulture that are nearing extinction. The government would provide the initial population of birds.

The cost of building the aviaries and maintaining the vultures is estimated at $5 million spread over 15 years, much less expensive than it would have been without the ready supply of food.

“Most vulture aviaries have to spend huge sums to buy meat, but for us that's free because the vultures will be feeding on human bodies - on us,” Mr. Mehta said.

Like the vultures on which they once relied, Parsis are disappearing. Their religion, Zoroastrianism, once dominated Iran but was largely displaced by Islam. In the 10th century, a large group of Zoroastrians fled persecution in Iran and settled in India. Fewer than 70,000 remain, most of them concentrated in Mumbai, formerly known as Bombay, where they collectively own prime real estate that was purchased centuries ago.

Among the most valuable of these holdings are 54 acres of trees and winding pathways on Malabar Hill, one of Mumbai's most exclusive neighborhoods. Tucked into these acres are three Towers of Silence where Parsis have for centuries disposed of their dead.

The stone towers are open-air auditoriums containing three concentric rings of marble slabs - an outer ring for dead men, middle ring for deceased women and inner ring for dead children. For centuries, bodies left on the slabs were consumed within hours by neighborhood vultures, with the bones left in a central catchment to leach into the soil.

Modernity has impinged on this ancient practice in many ways. That includes the construction of nearby skyscrapers where non-Parsis could watch the grisly scenes unfold. But by far the greatest threat has been the ecological disaster visited in recent years on vultures.

India once had as many as 400 million vultures, a vast population that thrived because the nation has one of the largest livestock populations in the world but forbids cattle slaughter. When cows died, they were immediately set upon by flocks of vultures that left behind skin for leather merchants and bones for bone collectors. As recently as the 1980s, even the smallest villages often had thousands of vulture residents.

But then came diclofenac, a common painkiller widely used in hospitals to lessen the pain of the dying. Marketed under names like Voltaren, it is similar to the medicines found in Advil and Aleve; in 1993 its use in India was approved in cattle. Soon after, vultures began dying in huge numbers because the drug causes them to suffer irreversible kidney failure.

Diclofenac's veterinarian use has since been banned, which may finally be having an effect. A recent study found that for the first time since the drug's introduction, India's vulture population did not decline over the past year.

Still, the numbers for three species have shrunk to only a few thousand, a tiny fraction of their former levels. With so few vultures left, the Parsi community set up mirrors around the Towers of Silence to create something akin to solar ovens to accelerate decomposition. But the mirrors are ineffective during monsoon months. So an increasing number of Parsis are opting for cremation, a practice many Parsi priests believe is an abomination since fire is sacred and corpses unclean.

Sruthi Gottipati contributed reporting.

A version of this article appeared in print on November 30, 2012, on page A18 of the New York edition with the headline: Giving New Life to Vultures to Restore a Human Ritual of Death.

Vinod Khosla Keeps Long-Term Bet on Clean Technology

Vinod Khosla crowed about the clean energy industry last year. Three of the biofuel start-ups in his venture capital portfolio had just gone public, and the stocks had risen considerably after their debuts. “I challenge anybody to claim that clean tech done right is a disaster,” Mr. Khosla said at a conference, rebuffing recent criticism. “We've generated more profits there than anybody has.”

Since then, Mr. Khosla, the founder of Khosla Ventures, has watched much of those paper gains evaporate. As the clean energy industry broadly has taken a hit, shares of the biofuel companies - Amyris, Gevo and KiOR - have slumped 70 percent to 90 percent from their peaks. His stakes, once worth as much as $1.3 billion, are now valued at roughly $378 million.

The billionaire investor has been caught in the cyclical downdraft.

The public stocks of solar, wind and biofuel companies are suffering amid industrywide pressures. The price of natural gas remains low. Europe has pulled back on incentives. American subsidies are in question after the bankruptcy of the solar panel maker Solyndra. And China is providing formidable low-cost competition.

“The whole clean tech sector has been out of favor,” said Pavel Molchanov, an analyst at Raymond James & Associates, a brokerage firm. “I'd be hard pressed to name one trading above its I.P.O. price.”

Despite the crosscurrents, Mr. Khosla seems unwavering in his commitment. He is pouring money into start-ups. Khosla Ventures recently invested more in LightSail Energy, a three-year-old start-up working to develop low-cost energy storage. He is also sticking with his public companies. His firm, for example, still owns 54 percent of KiOR.

“He's a visionary who likes to make big bets on ideas that can really change the world,” said Andy Bechtolsheim, who co-founded Sun Microsystems with Mr. Khosla 30 years ago and shares a house with him at Big Sur on the California c oast. “I would think he's made a larger personal bet on green tech than anybody else.”

While the public markets are raising short-term doubts, the long-term investment thinking remains unchanged. Governments around the globe are pushing to find alternative sources of energy in an effort to reduce their dependence on fossil fuels that may hurt the environment. In a television interview in 2007, Mr. Khosla said “mainstream solutions” could replace up to 80 percent of oil-based power. Without them, he said, “this planet is history the way we know it today.” After Hurricane Sandy, the subject of global warming - and changing climate conditions - has again come to the forefront.

In a recent blog post on the Forbes Web site, Mr. Khosla acknowledged the shift in market sentiment. “Clean tech went through a time when it was in vogue and now it is not,” he wrote. “The financing environment for clean tech companies is tough today,” he added. But he said he still expected “to do better than industry averages by keeping our losing companies to a minority.”

Since founding his venture capital firm in 2004, Mr. Khosla has become one of the most vocal advocates for clean tech innovation, buying stakes in about 60 industry start-ups. Ausra, a solar thermal start-up that had drawn $130 million in venture backing, was sold in 2010 to the French nuclear plant builder Areva for about $250 million, according to one industry estimate. And SeaMicro, a low-power server maker, was bought this year by Advanced Micro Devices for $334 million, more than five times the amount invested by its venture backers, according to a SeaMicro co-founder, Andrew Feldman.

It's unclear how the broader clean tech portfolio has performed at Khosla Ventures. Mr. Khosla declined to disclose the firm's returns or to comment for the article.

But one of his funds, which raised $1 billion to invest in clean tech and other start-ups, shows gai n of 30 percent since its inception in 2009, according to filings by the California Public Employees' Retirement System, the largest state pension fund. In his Forbes blog post, Mr. Khosla said a recent fund, which raised $1.05 billion in October 2011, was oversubscribed, and his firm's broader performance since 2006 had “well exceeded typical venture funds.” In that period, venture funds over all have returned 7.25 percent annually after fees, according to industry data.

Mr. Khosla's commitment is an outgrowth of his three decades at the cutting edge of technology.

A native of India, Mr. Khosla, 57, earned a master's degree in biomedical engineering from Carnegie Mellon and an M.B.A. from Stanford in 1980. After starting the design automation company Daisy Systems in 1982, he co-founded Sun Microsystems, then a growing technology company.

At Sun, he supplied drive and vision. But Mr. Khosla, who is known for his blunt talk and intense manner, was repla ced as chief executive two years later and left the company shortly thereafter.

In 1986, he joined the venture capital firm Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers. Over the next two decades, Mr. Khosla scored sizable returns betting on the growth of fiber optic networks. Two companies, Cerent and Siara Systems, were sold for a combined $15 billion-plus at the height of the late-1990s dot-com bubble.

Mr. Khosla was looking into alternative fuel technologies at Kleiner Perkins when a business plan for an ethanol start-up crossed his desk in 2003. The plan “sat on a corner of my desk for nearly 18 months while I read everything I could about petroleum and its alternatives,” he wrote in an article for Wired magazine in 2006.

When he branched out on his own in 2004, Mr. Khosla invested millions in the ethanol start-up, Celunol. He soon established himself as a top venture capitalist in clean tech, attracting prominent outside investors like Microsoft's founder, Bi ll Gates. Former Prime Minister Tony Blair of Britain joined the firm as a senior adviser.

Over the years, Mr. Khosla has experienced his share of blowups.

In September 2011, Khosla-backed Range Fuels, a wood-chips-to-ethanol company, went bankrupt after receiving a $44 million grant from the Department of Energy and $33 million under a Department of Agriculture loan guarantee. When The Wall Street Journal editorial page criticized Range Fuels as an “exercise in corporate welfare,” Mr. Khosla lashed back, saying the authors inhabited an “ivory tower” that was “full of people who don't understand technology.”

Sometimes, Mr. Khosla's companies had to pivot from their original plans and focus on new markets. For example, Calera was founded in 2007 with plans to use power plant exhaust to make cement. Mr. Khosla called its technology “game changing” in 2008.

But the company encountered some setbacks. It postponed plans for commercial-scale production in 2010 pending further research and later cut its 145-employee work force by two-thirds. Since then, Calera has broadened its focus, developing other products like fillers for paper and plastics.

Like many venture capital investors, Mr. Khosla will risk a few strikeouts for the chance to hit home runs. “My willingness to fail is what gives me the ability to succeed,” the investor has said frequently.

The odds can be especially brutal in clean technology. The projects are often capital-intensive - like $200 million or more for a biofuels plant - and they can take years to pay out, said Sam Shelton, a research engineer at Georgia Institute of Technology. By comparison, social media start-ups often require little upfront money and few employees. “The economics are totally different,” Mr. Shelton said.

In part, Mr. Khosla aims to take stakes when the companies are still getting off the ground, rather than waiting until they're more mature a nd more expensive. He first bought a stake in KiOR, which aims to convert wood chips to gas and diesel fuel, in 2007. The company is now completing the first of five planned plants in Mississippi with the help of a $75 million interest-free loan from the state.

Mr. Khosla is “always thinking at a very high level about the potential of an idea,” KiOR's chief executive, Fred Cannon, said. “He has a very good feel for when to step on the gas.”

After jumping in early, Mr. Khosla appears willing to ride out the swings, in both directions. Over the years, public filings indicate he has plowed roughly $80 million into KiOR, amassing a 54 percent stake in the company. Although the stock is off its peak levels and I.P.O. investors are still underwater, his holdings are worth $356 million - a threefold gain.

This post has been revised to reflect the following correction:

Correction: November 30, 2012

An earlier version of this article mischaracte rized Mr. Khosla's return on his investment in KiOR. He invested roughly $80 million and his holdings are worth $356 million - a threefold gain, not a fourfold gain.



The Trouble With \'Offbeat\' Essays Isn\'t the Style, but the Fit

Sush Krishnamoorthy, from New Delhi, is part of a “Choice” class that includes student-bloggers from Nairobi, Kenya; Topeka, Kan.; Seattle; Rogers, Ark.; Las Vegas; New York City; and Hunting Valley, Ohio. Her third post is below. - Tanya Abrams

When I started writing my college essays a month ago, I was lost in a sea of advice.

“Be yourself.”

“Find your voice.”

“Tell an interesting story.”

That wasn't very helpful.

In the beginning, I would a write a draft and read it again after two days. Most of those drafts found themselves in the recycle bin. My essays felt uninspired. Every idea I had sounded beautiful in my mind, but on paper it was all lost in translation.

A few months ago, I was confident that the essays would be a breeze because I often write accounts of experiences that touch me. But when application d eadlines were looming over my head, I felt out of my comfort zone. My life is ordinary. I couldn't think of any “offbeat” topics to write about.

One night, inspiration struck like lightning and I wrote 800 words about how an unaccompanied 24-hour flight changed me. Two days later, I was proud of my essay. So I refined it down to 493 words and proofread it a few times.

Then I asked a few people for feedback. There was criticism. Some said it wasn't very interesting, that maybe I should write about something fancier. Others said it was too simple in language.

When I opened the Word document to edit my essay, I realized that I didn't want to change anything about it. I meant every word I had written and it was really about who I am. So nobody else's opinion really matters, right?

I corrected a few grammatical errors and uploaded the file to my application.

After that, I was on a roll. I wrote all of the Common App and Stanford University supplement essays and was actually satisfied with them.

Now that I've submitted my application, sometimes I do wonder if I should have taken heed of the feedback. I guess I won't know until I receive my “envelopes.”

Ms. Krishnamoorthy, a student at Sardar Patel Vidyalaya in New Delhi, is one of eight high school seniors around the world blogging about their college searches for The Choice. To comment on what she has written here, please use the comment box below.



Internet Outage Reported Across Syria

Internet access disappeared all across Syria on Thursday, and airports were closed, prompting antigovernment activists to warn that the authorities might be planning to escalate their crackdown against the country's raging uprising. Only residents with their own satellite connections to the Internet could access the Web, activists said. Disruptions to phone service were also reported.

The network service provider Akamai posted a chart on Twitter showing the sudden drop off in Internet connections in Syria.

In a blog post reporting the outage, Jim Cowie, the chief technology officer of Renesys, a company based in New Hampshire that tracks Internet traffic, wrote:

Starting at 10:26 UTC (12:26pm in Damascus), Syria's international Internet connectivity shut down. In the global routing table, all 84 of Syria's IP address blocks have become unreachable, effectively removing the country from the Internet.

A representative of EgyptAir in Cairo told The Times that flights to Damascus, the Syrian capital, were suspended indefinitely and it was not clear when it will resume again. One opposition activist noted that an online flight-tracking Web site showed a blank spot over Syria.

In an update on the Web outage, Mr. Cowie added:

Looking closely at the continuing Internet blackout in Syria, we can see that traceroutes into Syria are failing, exactly as one would expect for a major outage. The primary autonomous system for Syria is the Syrian Telecommunications Establishment; all of their customer networks are currently unreachable.

Now, there are a few Syrian networks that are still connected to the Internet, still reachable by traceroutes, and indeed still hosting Syrian content. These are five networks that use Syrian-registered IP space, but the originator of the routes is actually Tata Communications. These are potentially offshore, rather than domestic, and perhaps not subject to whatever kill-switch was thrown today within Syria.

Opposition activists outside the country, who have relied on the Internet to distribute video documenting the uprising, scrambled to chart the contours of the communications disruption.

Some supporters of the Syrian government reported with dismay that parts of the country bordering Turkey were still online, thanks to connections to that

The Internet has been a strategic weapon for the uprising and the government alike, allowing activists to organize and communicate but also exposing them to surveillance. Fighters, activists and witnesses upload video of rebel exploits and atrocities by both government and rebel forces.

Our colleague C.J. Chivers, who has reported from inside Syria, notes that the government has done the same with electricity for many months - switching it on and off in various places” to disrupt the opposition. “Utility service can be both a carrot and a stick; in other words, a weapon of sorts.”

The Local Coordinating Committees, a coalition of Syrian activist groups, reported the outage in most parts of Damascus and in its suburbs as well as “most parts of the governorates of Hama, Homs, Dara'a; in all parts of the governorates of Tartous and Swaida; and in some cities in Deir Ezzor and Raqqa.”

At the height of the protests in Egypt in 2011, that country's authorities switched off the Internet to block opposition activists from communicating and documenting their rebellion. Internet access was also cut in Libya last year during the revolt that toppled Col. Muammar el-Qadaffi.

Fighting has been especially intense around Damascus over the past two weeks with rebels seizing air bases and weapons there. Rebels have put the government under increasing pressure in recent weeks taking oil fields in eastern Syria and a major air base outside Aleppo and demonstrating their increasing ability to shoot down aircraft.

Rebel advances are gr adually forcing the government to shrink the area it seeks to control and some analysts have speculated that if the govt felt core interests were threatened - if, for instance, Aleppo was in danger of being cut off from Damascus or the rebels succeeded in ringing the capital - the military might launch an even more desperate crackdown

“Deliberately or not the rebels could be forcing the regimes hand ” said Yezid Sayigh a military analyst at the Carnegie Middle East Center in Beirut.

The Internet cutoff apparently made some activists suspect that moment was at hand.

In a message distributed on Thursday, the Local Coordinating Committees said that they would “hold the regime responsible for any massacres that would be committed in any Syrian cities after such a move was made. Also, they call upon the world to move quickly and to take practical steps to protect civilians from the regime's crimes.”

The Beirut-based opposition blogger and journalist Shakeeb al-Jabri noted that while many antigovernment activists in Syria have access to the Web through other means, that is likely not true for many of the government's supporters.



Image of the Day: Nov. 29

A boat on the Dal Lake in Srinagar, Jammu and Kashmir. The Srinagar-Leh National Highway was closed for traffic, following heavy snowfall in the high altitude areas of the Kashmir valley, officials told local media.Tauseef Mustafa/Agence France-Presse - Getty ImagesA boat on the Dal Lake in Srinagar, Jammu and Kashmir. The Srinagar-Leh National Highway was closed for traffic, following heavy snowfall in the high altitude areas of the Kashmir valley, officials told local media.

Image of the Day: Nov. 29

A boat on the Dal Lake in Srinagar, Jammu and Kashmir. The Srinagar-Leh National Highway was closed for traffic, following heavy snowfall in the high altitude areas of the Kashmir valley, officials told local media.Tauseef Mustafa/Agence France-Presse - Getty ImagesA boat on the Dal Lake in Srinagar, Jammu and Kashmir. The Srinagar-Leh National Highway was closed for traffic, following heavy snowfall in the high altitude areas of the Kashmir valley, officials told local media.

Enforcement of India\'s Internet to Be Revised

The Facebook login page.Saeed Khan/Agence France-Presse - Getty ImagesThe Facebook login page.

The central government plans to revise the enforcement of a controversial Internet law that led to the arrest of two young women for their Facebook activity, a senior official in the Ministry of Communications and Information Technology said Thursday.

Last week, the police arrested Shaheen Dhada, 21, a medical student in Mumbai, after she posted a Facebook update questioning the forced citywide shutdown over the death of a far-right Hindu political leader. A friend who clicked “Like” on the post, Renu Srinivasan, 20, was also arrested. The arrests and the law used to justify them, the Information Technology Act, were sharply criticized by free speech advocates.

Communications Minister Kapil Sibal said Thursday that the ministry planned to ensure that senior police officials approve any future complaints before a case is registered under Section 66A of the law. The amendment, added in 2008, makes it a crime to digitally send “any information that is grossly offensive or has menacing character.”

The guidelines for this enforcement will be decided “at the earliest,” said J. Satyanarayana, the secretary of the Department of Electronics and Information Technology. They will be issued after consultations with several ministries including the Ministry of Home Affairs, he said.

“The implementation could be improved,” Mr. Satyanarayana said of the law, noting that the department plans to have police officers with the rank of inspector general or higher approve cases in states and those with the rank of deputy commissioner of police or hi gher in metropolitan cities.

The change follows the announcement Tuesday by R.R. Patil, the home minister of Maharashtra, the western state where the young women were arrested, that henceforth in cases involving violations of the I.T. Act, a senior officer would first investigate the matter and then a lawyer would be consulted before any action was taken.

On Thursday, Shreya Singhal, a young law student from Delhi, filed public interest litigation with the Supreme Court, challenging the constitutionality of Section 66A. The court is scheduled to hear the case Friday.



At Sundance Film Festival, A Strong Showing From India

Three films competing at the 2013 Sundance Film Festival in January have an India connection, the best representation for India at the American festival in five years.

Sundance announced its list of films on Wednesday. Two entries come from India, and a third is a United States entry about India.

The American director Steve Hoover's film “Blood Brother” is about a “disillusioned” American tourist who decides to stay in India after meeting a group of children with H.I.V. The film is competing in the U.S. Documentary category.

“Fire in the Blood,” directed by Dylan Mohan Gray, who holds dual Indian and Canadian citizenship, is an entry in the World Cinema Documentary category. The film “tells the story of how Western pharmaceutical companies and governments blocked access to low-cost AIDS drugs for the countries of the global south after 1996,” according to its Web site.

The British director Kim Longinotto's film “Salma” has been nominated as a joint entry from Britain and India in the World Cinema Documentary competition. It tells the story of a young girl from South India who is locked away by her parents when she reaches puberty, a plight that befalls “millions of other girls around the world,” according to the film's summary.  After more than two decades, she finds her way back to the world outside and goes on to become a writer.

Ms. Longinotto is known for making films centered on women; her film “Rough Aunties,” about a group of women in South Africa who look after “abused, neglected and forgotten children” from the city of Durban, won the jury prize at the 2009 Sundance festival in the Wo rld Cinema Documentary category.

At the 2012 Sundance festival, “Valley of Saints,” an entry from India and the United States, won the World Cinema Audience Award in the Dramatic category.  The film, based in Srinagar, Jammu and Kashmir, is about Gulzar, a boatman who decides to escape the valley in search of a better life. But life has other plans, and he finds himself assisting a scientist in an environmental study at the Dal Lake in Srinagar.  The Sundance jury praised the film for its “brave, poetic and visually arresting evocation of a beautiful but troubled region, and for its moving, nuanced and accurate depiction of the relationship between a local boatman and a young woman scientist whose research challenges the status quo and offers hope for a restored ecosystem.”

There was no other entry from India in 2012.

At the 2011 festival, India was also represented by just one film, a joint entry from India, the United States and Britain in the W orld Cinema Documentary category. “The Bengali Detective,” set in Kolkata, followed the adventures of an “overweight dance-obsessed intrepid detective.”

Though the movie won no awards at the festival, its portrayal of Rajesh Ji, a real-life detective, caught the eye of Fox Searchlight Pictures, which acquired worldwide remake rights from Native Voice Films.

In 2010, a more mainstream Indian movie, Anusha Rizvi's “Peepli (Live),” the tale of a farmer who decides to commit suicide so that his family will receive compensation from the government, was entered in the World Cinema Narrative competition. The film, which was also India's official entry to the Oscars that year, did not pick up an award at Sundance.

There were no films from India at Sundance in 2008 or 2009.



India\'s Hidden Health Care Labor Force

A clinic in Kavarapattu, Thanjavur, Tamil Nadu, run by Sughavazhvu, an organization which provides health care in rural areas.Courtesy of Zeena Johar/SughavazhvuA clinic in Kavarapattu, Thanjavur, Tamil Nadu, run by Sughavazhvu, an organization which provides health care in rural areas.

As India grapples with the daunting challenge of providing health care to the millions who can't afford or access it, a growing number of “affordable health care” entrepreneurs are focused on developing new solutions for the rural and remote parts of the country.

One such initiative is gaining steam in Thanjavur in Tamil Nadu, where IKP Center for Technologies in Public Health has partnered with a local nonprofit, Sughava zhvu Healthcare, to set up a network of well-equipped health centers that provide a broad range of health care services.

“In India, money is not the problem,” said Nachiket Mor, a public health expert who is an IKP Center director and chairman of Sughavazhvu Healthcare. ”Manpower is not the problem. We just need to create and demonstrate on the ground how a primary health care system can work,” he said.

A physician examining a patient in Sughavazhvu's rural clinic in Andipatti, Thanjavur, Tamil Nadu.Courtesy of Zeena Johar/SughavazhvuA physician examining a patient in Sughavazhvu's rural clinic in Andipatti, Thanjavur, Tamil Nadu.

The pilot, not-for-profit pro ject is currently running seven facilities, which, Mr. Mor said, “could act as model primary health subcenters.” Each center has protocols for the treatment of a wide range of ailments, including cardiovascular diseases, diabetes, anemia, oral health, women's health and reproductive care, ophthalmic care and even mental health counseling and treatment.

Across India, access to health care remains a pressing problem, exacerbated by the country's large population and shortage of doctors. Nowhere is this challenge more acute than in rural India, which is experiencing a severe shortage of qualified health care practitioners. According to Health Ministry statistics, the doctor-to-patient ratio for rural India is one to 30,000; the World Health Organization recommends a ratio of one to 1,000.

This leaves the health of rural populations largely in the hands of people who aren't always fully qualified, including family elders, midwives and doulas, untrained community health workers and accredited social health activists (known as ASHA workers) who merely refer patients up the chain to specialists and bigger-city hospitals, Mr. Mor said.

The Indian government has tried to fill this gap by providing low-cost care through rural health centers, called “subcenters,” in villages, tasked with offering primary care. But often they are empty rooms, Mr. Mor said, with little or no qualified staff or facilities.

The Tamil Nadu pilot program is intended to show that it is possible to provide continuous, quality health care for rural communities by using village-based “health extension workers” to assist doctors.

What Mr. Mor calls his “game changer” is India's large talent pool of what are known as “Ayush” doctors, practitioners of Ayurveda, Unani and Siddha medicine, who are trained in indigenous medical education. (Unani medicine originated in the Arab world, while Siddha is from Tamil Nadu.) There are 750,000 qua lified and registered Ayush practitioners who are currently severely underutilized, he said.

“In our view this talent pool is already large,” he said. “Their services can much more easily be expanded and utilized than the pool of physicians trained in allopathic care,” that is, conventional modern medicine.

These doctors already have much of the training they need, Mr. Mor said, as there is an 80 percent overlap between the curricula they follow to become Ayush doctors and the international M.D. curriculum.

The  project trains and certifies these indigenous doctors to serve as “independent care providers” in a rural setting. A Supreme Court judgment made it legal for Ayush doctors to practice conventional medicine, provided they follow certain  regulations. The training program has been developed in partnership with the University of Pennsylvania's School of Nursing.

Mr. Mor said he hopes to find private sector players or state governme nts to partner with to set up similar facilities across the country. He is in talks with private and state partners in Odisha and Uttaranchal, he said.

He brings to the project his experience as a part of the government committee on universal health coverage instituted by the Planning Commission, which has recommended the establishment of a National Healthcare Reform Commission. It has also recommended the introduction of a new three-year Bachelor of Rural Health Care (BRHC) university program to train rural health care practitioners, double the number of community health workers in rural areas and recruit adequate numbers of dentists, pharmacists, physiotherapists and technicians.

Other countries are also trying to create a cadre of rural health care professionals, and the nongovernment sector has often stepped in when the state has shown reluctance or complacence.

In Bangladesh, for instance, BRAC, the world's largest development organization, is in the p rocess of training 80,000 community health care providers who, like paramedics, will be taught essential services such as maternal and child health care. They will be able to go door to door to provide services in the poorest parts of the country, Asif Saleh, BRAC's senior director, said from Dhaka.

Read more about the affordable healthcare market, and what a fund founded by eBay's Pierre Omidyar's is doing in the sector.

Jyoti Pande Lavakare is an author and columnist who has covered entrepreneurs from India and Silicon Valley, including producing features for All India Radio in New Delhi, and writing columns for Mint and the Business Standard. She is currently working on her first novel, “The Memory of Pain.”



Wednesday, November 28, 2012

In India \'Paid News\' Soars With Competition

Naveen Jindal, managing director of Jindal Steel and Power and a member of Parliament, in this March 5, 2012 file photo.Sajjad Hussain/Agence France-Presse - Getty ImagesNaveen Jindal, managing director of Jindal Steel and Power and a member of Parliament, in this March 5, 2012 file photo.

On Indian television news, hidden cameras are often used to catch a politician accepting a bribe or a big business giving one. A recent “sting” operation also had a conglomerate's executives on camera, but it was the journalists who got stung.

They film appears to show journalists saying they would stop unfavorable coverage of a steel company's suspected involvement in a coal scam if about $18 million o f advertising revenue was committed to their news network. The journalists claim the film was doctored, but late on Tuesday, they were arrested for criminal conspiracy and extortion â€" charges unusual, and shocking, for journalists in India.

India has thriving and noisy news media; hundreds of English, Hindi and regional news channels offer round-the-clock coverage of news. India's television business has been on steroids the last 20 years since the government liberalized broadcasting. But analysts say that many TV networks struggle in turning a profit because of cutthroat competition for the same pool of advertising dollars.

“There are too many new entrants,” said Sevanti Ninan, the editor of The Hoot, a Web site devoted to media criticism, arguing that even the big players “are financially vulnerable.”

Media watchdogs have been critical of a paid news phenomenon that has soared along with this growth of media. In the past, there have also been reports about paid news coverage of political parties and candidates during state and national elections, as well as more routine blurring of news and advertising content in major publications. This has all led to a debate of ethics in journalism in India. With  arrests Tuesday, a debate of criminality in journalism has also been brought into the picture.

Analysts say the case reeks of the toxic mix of news with business and politics.

The television editors of channels Zee News, Sudhir Chaudhary, and Zee Business, Samir Ahluwalia, came under the spotlight when the company Jindal Steel and Power, one of India's major steel producers, filed a complaint in October. Both the editors are heads of news as well as business operations of their channel.

The steel company accused them of trying to extort money to stop news coverage of allegations of the company's involvement in a $34 billion coal mining scandal that has engulfed the countr y in recent months. That scam, dubbed Coalgate, has centered on the opaque government allotment process that enabled well-connected businessmen and politicians to obtain rights to undeveloped coal fields. The steel company also produced a CD to back their claims.

Zee company officials, however, counter that the steel company was trying to bribe them to slow their coverage. The chairman of the steel company, Naveen Jindal, a lawmaker with the ruling Indian National Congress party and one of India's richest industrialists, was reportedly under investigation in connection to the coal scam.

“In pursuit of seeking truth in the Coalgate scam, we have had several interactions with Jindal and with his officials. He chose to display an edited/ doctored CD where only selected portions are shown. Mr. Jindal has a history of unfairly targeting those who dare to confront him with the truth,” Mr. Chaudhary and Mr. Ahluwalia said on their Web site last month.

Paranjoy Guha Thakurta, an independent journalist and educator, said the arrests of senior journalists would have been unlikely if people who don't have Mr. Jindal's influence were involved.

“He happens to be a member of Parliament. He happens to be a member of the ruling party,” Mr.  Thakurta said.

On Wednesday, Zee network maintained its innocence and described the complaint of Mr. Jindal's company as “fraudulent and contrived.” In a press conference, the chief executive of Zee News, Alok Agrawal, and the company's lawyer said that the arrests were orchestrated to deflect attention on the coal scam and were an attack on press freedom.

“Just because they are editors, it doesn't give them immunity,” Rajeev Bhadauria, director of human resources at Jindal steel told NDTV news channel, saying that freedom of the press had nothing to do with it. “They are the rotten apples and need to be weeded out.”

Mr. Jindal declined to comment to the Indian news media.

Analysts, while declining to comment on the specifics of this case as it is still under investigation, note that it's not uncommon for stories in the Indian news media to be held back because of pressure from industrialists.

“There's no sense of right and wrong among big media houses,” said Ms. Ninan, adding that although there are exceptions, “The grip of big business is growing. It does not make for very courageous journalism taking place on matters of corruption.”



Bidding Farewell to the Jewel of the Lotus

Aaron Putnam, a postdoctoral researcher at the Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory of Columbia University, led an expedition to Bhutan to examine links among climate, glaciers and water resources in the Himalaya. This is his final post.

Ed Cook of the Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory of Columbia University and Paul Krusic of Stockholm University compared samples of Juniper shrubs in the Thampe Chhu river valley.Mike Roberts Ed Cook of the Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory of Columbia University and Paul Krusic of Stockholm University compa red samples of Juniper shrubs in the Thampe Chhu river valley.

Friday, Nov. 2

A long, tiring drive over a narrow, cliff-bound gravel road took us westward from Sephu back to Thimpu. We dropped Tshewang Rigzin and Pashupati Ssarma at their respective houses, and finally arrived at our hotel where David Putnam and I were met by an enthusiastic and relieved Ed Cook and Paul Krusic. After checking into our room, we compared notes on our respective journeys out of the mountains from Rinchen Zoe.

Ed and Paul said that as they were taking their final steps out of the mountains, they could see the growing storm that would bring blizzard conditions to our high camp at Rinchen Zoe La. Needless to say, they were concerned about our welfare and were doubly relieved to see that we made it from the field site unscathed.

Paul Krusic cored an ancient Juniper near the Timberline beneath Tampe La.Mike Roberts Paul Krusic cored an ancient Juniper near the Timberline beneath Tampe La.

We recounted our saga to Ed and Paul, and they filled us in on theirs. They were able to exit the mountains on schedule for Mike Roberts to catch his flight. The good news was that Ed, Paul, and Karma Tenzin of the Council for Renewable Natural Resources were able to make a reconnaissance collection of samples from the ancient juniper trees growing at the timberline below Tampe La.

These will be among the highest growing trees they have sampled in Bhutan. Ed and Paul were excited about the possibility of reconstructing several centuries of atmospheric temperature from these trees, though they wished that there had been more time to build a larger sample collection. This is clearly a prom ising avenue for further research.

Soon it was time for dinner, and it turns out that our arrival coincided with the departure of Summer Rupper and her student, Josh Maurer.

Professor Summer Rupper and her student, Josh Maurer, worked on Drukso Gangri.Mike Roberts Professor Summer Rupper and her student, Josh Maurer, worked on Drukso Gangri.

They decided to delay their ride to the airport in Paro for one more dinner with the team. Our group met at the local pizza restaurant in Thimpu, whose specialty is the dangerously spicy “Devil's Pizza.” Also joining us for dinner was Phuntsho Namgyal, who had been so instrumental in helping to plan the logistics for the excursion.

Even though only weeks had passed since we were last in Thimpu together, and even though many of the team members had first met upon our arrival in Bhutan, it felt like a reunion of old friends. Notably absent were Scott Travis, who was afflicted with altitude sickness and had to turn back early in the trip, and Mike Roberts, who departed Bhutan the previous day.

After dinner, Summer and Josh were escorted to Paro and they departed Bhutan.

The next day, David, Paul, Ed and I were to convene at the Ministry of Economic Affairs where I was to deliver a formal debriefing lecture for Karma Tshering, director of the Department of Hydromet Services, and his colleagues. Tshewang met us at our hotel, where he dressed David and me each in a formal gho, which is the traditional male dress of Bhutan (and also requires a fundamental level of skill to put on, which neither David or I possessed).

Ed and Paul were simultaneously dressed, and we were es corted to the department building. I delivered the debriefing lecture for the glacial geology portion of our research. In previous days, while we were still on the trail, Summer and Ed had delivered debriefing lectures on the glaciology and dendrochronology components of the field work.

A debriefing at the Ministry of Economic Affairs, Department of Hydromet Services.Tsencho Dorji A debriefing at the Ministry of Economic Affairs, Department of Hydromet Services.

My lecture focused primarily on the motivations, methods, and expectations for our attempt to discern the record of past glacier fluctuations from Rinchen Zoe. Of particular interest to Karma and his colleagues was the potential for reconstruct ing fluctuations of mountain snowlines in response to ongoing climate change.

Hydropower in Bhutan is generated largely from runoff resulting from melting snow in the mountains. Thus, any upward migration of the mountain snowline will serve to shrink the existing snowpack available to melt throughout the summer, and diminish the amount of power that can be generated.

Glacier extents hinge on the altitude of mountain snowlines. So if we can use the record of past mountain glaciation to determine how past climate changes have influenced mountain snowline altitudes, then it will be easier to anticipate how rapidly the snowpack will diminish with future warming.

The glacier teamin the Rinchen Zoe field area.  Standing, from left to right: Sangay, Tshewang Rigzin, Pashupati Ss   arma, Mike Roberts, Summer Rupper, David Putnam and the author.  Kneeling, from left to right: Sangay K., Karma Tshering, Josh Maurer and our wonderful cook.Mike Roberts The glacier team'in the Rinchen Zoe field area. Standing, from left to right: Sangay, Tshewang Rigzin, Pashupati Ssarma, Mike Roberts, Summer Rupper, David Putnam and the author. Kneeling, from left to right: Sangay K., Karma Tshering, Josh Maurer and our wonderful cook.

Our discussions combined elements of cross-cultural communication, as well as the void between geologists, who strive to understand how things come to be, and engineers, who are concerned with how to put those things to use. We discussed the water derived from the monsoon versus the winter snowpack, as well as the possible impact of a strengthening monsoon on glaciers.

Again we confronted our differing research questions and expected outcomes. It would take a late r visit from Professors Joerg Schaefer and Peter Schlosser of the Earth Institute at Columbia University to iron out those issues to everyone's satisfaction.

Our last major task involved shipping the samples back to Columbia University. We had spent five weeks traveling, 16 days walking in the mountains, and several days on the winding mountain roads to collect those 57 bags of rock, and it was imperative that they make it safely to the laboratory in New York. Tshewang and Phuntsho had acquired the necessary export permits, and to our delight, the precious 200 or so pounds of samples were whisked away without issue by the local air carrier office.

David and I spent our last day in Thimpu purchasing bundled prayer flags in the open market by the river, kiras for our wives, and visiting the “zoo” to see Bhutan's national animal, the takin. After noon, we loaded up a Department of Hydromet Services vehicle for the one-hour drive on the tortuous road to Paro.< /p>

Sitting on a high promontory above the Paro valley, we surveyed the ancient pattern of rice paddies, Paro Dzong on a rock outcrop over the river, and the walled Royal Palace complex as the sun set. That evening, in the corner of the hotel lobby where the wireless signal was the strongest, I was interviewed by Marco Werman of PRI's “The World” via Skype.

The next day David and I made the obligatory pilgrimage to the Taktsang Monastery, precariously perched on cliffs above Paro. The steep trail up the mountain is punctuated by clusters of prayer flags, prayer wheels, and prayer mills, where tiny rivulets are harnessed to turn a prayer wheel and send the jewel at the heart of the lotus, Om Mani Padme Hum, downstream to the masses in India and Bangladesh.

The following morning we again boarded a Druk Air flight bound for Delhi. Seated on the right side of the plane we were graced with a day of pure, clear, mountain air. The sacred snow-cone of Jomolhari was the first to rise into sight, followed in awesome succession by Kanchenjunga, Makalu, Everest and the great spine of the world stretching eastward to Afghanistan.

We re-entered the modern world in the New Delhi Indira Gandhi International Airport, the past five weeks in Bhutan rapidly becoming a memory as fleeting as a prayer carried on a mountain breeze. We had experienced the uncompromising freedom of the high mountains and had fled back to the shackles of our lives.

David's furrowed brow reflected renewed worry about his courses and students at the University of Maine at Presque Isle. I began fretting about the samples, and speeding up the geochemistry. The envelope of random receipts promised days of accounting for the expense report.

A last glimpse of the Hima   laya, featuring Jomulhari or 'bride of Kanchenjunga,' at the head of the Paro Chhu river.David Putnam A last glimpse of the Himalaya, featuring Jomulhari or ‘bride of Kanchenjunga,' at the head of the Paro Chhu river.

Fog prevented our landing in Newark and after a grueling flight from Delhi we sat on an abandoned runway in Newburgh, N.Y., for several hours. David missed his connecting flights, and my wife, Katherine, picked me up hours late in Newark and whisked me home to our apartment in Tappan, N.Y.

The normal routine of life had almost resumed, and then - Hurricane Sandy! But that is a tale for another blog.